Revocable and Irrevocable Letters of Credit

Revocable and Irrevocable Letters of Credit

Revocable Letters of Credit: Revocable letter of credit can be modified or cancelled by the issuing bank after its issuance at any moment without seeking the beneficiary’s consent.

There is one exception regarding the revocation of the credit.

Issuing bank must reimburse any nominated or confirming bank with which the revocable letter of credit has been made available if these banks fulfill their obligations under the documentary credit terms against complying presentation before they receive the amendment or cancellation notice from the issuing bank.

A revocable letter of credit can serve as a limited security payment method to the beneficiaries, because they are subject to amendment or cancellation without their prior knowledge.

As a result revocable letters of credit are not used frequently in international trade.

UCP 500,which is the previous letters of credit rules published by ICC, was indicated that a letter of credit may be either revocable or irrevocable.

UCP 500 assumed that a letter of credit is irrevocable in default of the indication whether it is revocable or irrevocable.

Current letter of credit rules, UCP 600, do not cover revocable letters of credit. This point is made clear in article 3 of UCP 600:

A credit is irrevocable even if there is no indication to that effect.

Irrevocable Letter of Credit: Irrevocable Letter Of Credit (ILOC) is a letter of credit type which can not be cancelled or amended by the issuing bank without the agreement of the parties of the letter of credit transaction.

For example, issuing bank has no power to modify letter of credit terms if beneficiary does not find them acceptable.

In other words, every amendment at least requires beneficiary’s acceptance in order to be effective.

Irrevocable letters of credit give much more payment security to the beneficiaries than revocable letters of credit because of the reasons explained above. As a result, irrevocable letters of credit are the types of LCs that dominantly seen on the market place.

Banks will only add their confirmation to the irrevocable letters of credit. A confirming bank is not obligated to add its confirmation to any amendment. Also, transferable letters of credit should not be issued in a revocable form.

Letters of credits are transmitted through banks via a secure and authenticated system which is called SWIFT.

There are various swift message types for different situations. For example banks use MT700 (Message Type 700) when issuing a letter of credit.

We will examine SWIFT messages in detail later on.

Here we want to explain one section of MT700 swift message (Issue of a Documentary Credit) which contains the information regarding the type of the documentary credit.

In order to understand the letter of credit type we need to check Field 40A in a MT700 swift message. This field contains the necessary information regarding the form of the documentary credit. There are seven possibilities as seen below.

  • IRREVOCABLE : The documentary credit is irrevocable.
  • REVOCABLE: The documentary credit is revocable.
  • IRREVOCABLE TRANSFERABLE: The documentary credit is irrevocable and transferable.
  • REVOCABLE TRANSFERABLE: The documentary credit is revocable and transferable.
  • IRREVOCABLE STANDBY: The standby letter of credit is irrevocable.
  • REVOCABLE STANDBY: The standby letter of credit is revocable.
  • IRREVOC TRANS STANDBY: The standby letter of credit is irrevocable and transferable.

What is Irrevocable Letter of Credit? Definition and Application

irrevocable-letter-of-credit-definition-application

Irrevocable letter of credit (ILOC) is a type of documentary credit which can not be cancelled or amended by the issuing bank without the agreement of the parties of the letter of credit transaction.

The letter of credit world is full of misunderstandings, improper industry practices including irregular banking practices, false information and so on.

Irrevocable letter of credit term is not an exception.

Many traders attribute irrelevant or false meanings to this term.

Let me give you a quick example: A trade manager once told me that he will secure the payment from his bank as long as he will receive an irrevocable letter of credit from his buyer.

He was mistakenly believing that the irrevocable letter of credit give him %100 payment assurance. But this is not true.

Definition of an Irrevocable Letter of Credit?

We can define an irrevocable letter of credit (ILOC) as a type of documentary credit which can not be cancelled or amended by the issuing bank without the agreement of the parties of the letter of credit transaction.

Table 1 shows the parties to the irrevocable letter of credit transaction.

If the letter of credit is confirmed, then the parties of the letter of credit are the issuing bank, confirming bank and the beneficiary.

If the letter of credit is not confirmed, then only the issuing bank and the beneficiary are the parties of the irrevocable letter of credit transaction.

irrevocable letter of credit parties
Table 1 : Parties to the irrevocable letter of credit
  • Issuing bank can not cancel or amend an unconfirmed irrevocable letter of credit without the written consent of the beneficiary.
  • Issuing bank can not cancel or amend a confirmed irrevocable letter of credit without the written consent of the beneficiary and the confirming bank.

As illustrated above, the beneficiary of an irrevocable letter of credit knows that the terms and conditions of the credit can not be changed without his approval.

Also, he knows that the l/c will not be cancelled either.

But does this mean that the beneficiary have %100 payment guaranty under an irrevocable l/c. As I said earlier. No.

Let me write down my reasons,

  • Letter of credit is a conditional payment method. In order to be getting paid under a letter of credit, irrevocable or revocable, the beneficiary has to make a complying presentation. In simple words, the beneficiary has to make the shipment and collect all trade documents requested under the l/c and present them to the issuing bank (nominated bank or confirming bank in some cases). Afterwards, the issuing bank will check the documents and pays the credit amount to the beneficiary only if the documents are found to be compliant.
  • If issuing bank finds that the documents are non-compliant, then the issuing bank will send an advice of refusal to the beneficiary. The issuing bank sends the advice of a refusal as a swift message, MT 734 Advice of a Refusal.

Once the beneficiary has received the advice of the refusal from the issuing bank, he has 3 options.

  1. If the beneficiary has still enough time to correct the documents, he may try to do so by submitting new documents. But it is mostly not possible due to two major time constraints for a new presentation: The expiry date of the letter of credit and period for presentation of the documents.
  2. The second option of the beneficiary would be to apply the importer to accept the discrepancies.
  3. The final option would be recalling the documents from the issuing bank and trying to find a new buyer to the goods.

Conclusion:

A revocable letter of credit may be amended or cancelled by the issuing bank at any moment and without prior notice to the beneficiary.

Irrevocable letter of credit, on the other hand, can not be cancelled or amended by the issuing bank without the agreement of the parties of the letter of credit transaction.

According to the latest letter of credit rules (UCP 600) all credits are irrevocable.

Letter of credit is a conditional payment obligation of the issuing bank and the beneficiary always has to make a complying presentation in order to receive the payment.

Types of Letters of Credit

Types of Letters of Credit

From their origins in 18th-century traveler’s credit systems to today’s cornerstone role in international commerce, letters of credit (LCs) have transformed into all-round, secure financial instruments critical for mitigating risk in cross-border transactions.

These tools are broadly categorized into commercial letters of credit—the go-to payment method for facilitating trade deals—and standby letters of credit, which act as safety nets for contractual obligations.

Beyond these core types, specialized variations like red clause, confirmed, transferable, and back-to-back letters of credit offer tailored solutions to meet the unique demands of buyers and sellers.

In this post, we break down the different types of letters of credit and how they secure global transactions.

Read more